- Main
Three Applied Economic Studies in Collaboration with Government Policymakers
- Garz, Seth Aaron Levine
- Advisor(s): de Janvry, Alain
Abstract
This manuscript features three independent applications of contemporary
techniques in applied economics conducted in collaboration with three different
governments. In the first essay, I present findings from an experimental
intervention conducted in collaboration with the government of the Dominican
Republic in which the government varies whether front-line volunteer
community workers are recruited through a public advertisement or through
local staff referrals. I find that governments likely face tradeoffs in selecting
optimal recruiting mechanisms as publicly recruited candidates demonstrate
superior observable characteristics to referred candidates across a wide variety of
indicators except for the key indicator of cognitive skills. I also find public
candidates are more likely to accept job offers and attend trainings conditional
on being hired. To my knowledge, this is the first study to rigorously test the
impacts of an open public recruitment process versus a private targeted
recruitment process.
In the second essay, my co-author and I evaluate impacts of a World Bank
funded road improvement and employment generation intervention in
Nicaragua. We employ a difference-in-difference research design, matching
proprietary road building data from the government of Nicaragua’s Ministry of
Transportation with three rounds of a publicly available household survey. We
find strong evidence that the World Bank’s Fourth Roads Rehabilitation and
Maintenance Project fulfilled its primary goal of improving road infrastructure
and suggestive evidence of select economic and social impacts. Notably, we do
not observe impacts on the likelihood of employment or incidence of poverty.
In the third essay, I collaborate with the City of San Francisco’s Office of
the Treasurer to investigate mechanisms that potentially mediate household
decisions to save for distant future expenditures with particular relevance for
education-oriented savings. Employing a randomized experiment in the natural
setting of the Kindergarten-to-College school district-wide college savings
program, I vary the messages of postcard savings reminders with information
about either the availability of college financial aid or the increasing cost of
tuition. My results suggest that savings reminders may overcome inattention to
lumpy future expenditures, but only among those who intended to save. I find
no evidence that manipulating the salience of college cost affects savings
behavior.
Main Content
Enter the password to open this PDF file:
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-